Skip to content

Driving Age Debate Essay Topics

It's a question that could reverberate across the country, wherever a new teen driver is turning a key in an ignition.

Is 16 the right age to get a driver's license?

Researchers for the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety say the answer is no, and they point to statistics to back up the position that raising the driving age makes sense and would save lives.

The insurance institute has pressed the question for years. At this week's annual meeting of the Governors Highway Safety Association in Scottsdale, Ariz., institute President Adrian Lund is going to push it further. Although Lund doesn't expect to lobby state legislatures, he said Monday he will advocate for a higher minimum driving age in his speech Tuesday.

Linnea Greci sees the issue a little differently. Then again, she's 15.

"I don't think it matters what age you are," the Hinsdale Central High School sophomore said Monday before hitting the road for her driver's education class, "as long as you have the practice and experience."

The institute's 17-page report collects research on the minimum driving age from the United States and countries that have higher licensing ages. The research shows states are making progress in reducing the No. 1 killer of teens—motor vehicle crashes—through graduated driver licensing. The laws ease restrictions on teen drivers as they gain experience and keep a clean driving record.

In recent years Illinois has enacted teen driving reforms, many of them after the Tribune's "Teens at the Wheel" series in 2006 examined ways that fatalities might be reduced. The state reforms included doubling the number of adult-supervised hours required behind the wheel to get a driver's license and tripling the length of time a new teen driver must possess a learner's permit. Some credit those changes for significant declines in teen driving deaths in the first seven months of this year.

But "we're still losing a lot of teens on the road each year," Lund said. Motor vehicle crashes kill more than 5,000 teenagers every year.

"This is kind of the next logical step," he said of the insurance institute's push to raise the minimum age. "Do these teens need to be driving as early as we are allowing them to drive?"

In a prepared statement for release Tuesday, the institute contends research shows "that licensing at later ages would substantially reduce crashes involving teen drivers."

The example the institute uses most prominently is New Jersey, the only state with a minimum driver's license age of 17. The report cited a study from 1992-96 in which the rate of crash-related deaths among 16- and 17-year-olds was 18 per 100,000 in New Jersey, compared with 26 per 100,000 in Connecticut, which had a minimum driver's license age of 16 and 4 months.

Neither New Jersey nor Connecticut had graduated licensing laws at the time of the study.

The report also showed that the New Jersey fatality rate fell significantly for teens after a graduated licensing law was enacted. Among the state's 17-year-old drivers, the percentage in fatal crashes dropped 33 percent after the law was enacted.

A combination of factors contributes to make teenagers poor drivers. Much of it centers on the complexity of driving and teens' tendency to speed more and use seat belts less than older drivers.

Also, the teen brain is at a particularly vulnerable point in development. Fifteen- and 16-year-olds have the logical reasoning of an adult, experts say. But their young minds' social and emotional development remains relatively immature and voraciously seeks sensual arousal, novelty and risk.

The teenage brain also is particularly vulnerable to distraction and peer pressure, and is undergoing explosive development. The front portion of the brain—which includes control of impulses, judgment and decision-making, and the coordination of multi-tasking—matures deep into the 20s, research shows.

But veteran driver's education teachers are skeptical about raising the age when a teenager can get a license.

"That's like saying we're not going to let any kid get near a pool or lake or the ocean and the drownings will go down," said Brent Johnston, a driving teacher at Hinsdale Central since 1974. "I think Illinois has gone the proper way—reward the kids who do a nice job and penalize the kids who don't. The teen driving issues are not about age and maturity as much as they are about making good choices and demonstrating exceptional behavior, whether they start that driving experience at 16, 17 or 18."

Added Ken Biggs, chairman of the driver's education department at Schaumburg High School: "Idealistically, I think it'd be great" to raise the minimum age. "But practically? No. There's no mass transit to get to work, to get to jobs."

State Rep. John D'Amico (D- Chicago), who proposed raising the driving age to 18 in 2006, and Secretary of State Jesse White, who proposed many of the reforms enacted this year, said teen driving deaths have continued dropping in Illinois since the laws were strengthened.

Both noted recent Illinois Department of Transportation figures that show 49 teens were killed in motor vehicle crashes through this July compared with 93 who died in the same period last year.D'Amico said he's satisfied for now that the reforms are working but is open to reviving a push for a higher minimum driving age if the improvements stagnate or if deaths rise. Surveys reviewed by the insurance institute show more than 50 percent of adults support higher licensing ages.

Ryan Moore, 16, of Schaumburg got his driver's license in June. He said, "I think it would be better to wait," but he needed his license as soon as possible. Both parents work, and he had to get himself from football practice to his job as a lifeguard.

"I've driven with some people who are horrible drivers even though they've been driving for a while," Moore said. "And I've driven with people who haven't been driving very long but are pretty good. Some people are ready, and some people aren't."

tgregory@tribune.com

Should The Legal Driving Age Be Changed? Essay

578 Words3 Pages

Do you really want to be stuck at home until you’re 18 doing nothing with your free time while your parents are gone? Don’t you want to be able to roam around places and probably take extracurricular activities on your own time and hang with friends too? Being able to drive is what many children in our society think about these days. When many teenagers reach the age of 15 ½ they are allowed to officially take their permit test to receive their permit for driving with an adult. After they have officially turned 16 they may take the behind-the wheel driving exam for a driver’s license, but the USA plans to change the driving age from 16 to 18. This idea seems to be a mistake seen in many ways. I believe that they shouldn’t change the…show more content…

While taking drivers education, you are tested and taught about all the rules of the roads and shown many reasons to follow these roads. For example, if you didn’t follow the speed limit signs, you are most likely to be given a ticket and fined a couple hundred dollars. While you are driving with an adult, they will supervise you and tell you what things you are doing wrong so that you will not make the mistake again. This way, you’ll be sure not to make the same mistakes while taking your driver’s test. After you’ve received your learners permit, you are required to complete a minimum of six hours of behind-the wheel training with a professional driver. When taking the behind-the wheel training, you will be tested on many roads and areas so your trainer will know what you are doing wrong and will teach you the correct way. All of these abilities are great for becoming the safest and best driver.

Right now in the United States, we have started a hard economic time. Many people are getting laid off and lots are losing their money. If teenagers were able to drive by themselves, they could find a job and transport themselves their without a parent. This would save the parent’s time and they wouldn’t have to spend their own money on gas since it isn’t their car. This way, we will be teaching our children responsibility also. The parents can also have their own teen

Show More