Skip to content

Holinsheds Chronicles Macbeth Comparison Essay

Essay on Shakespeare Alterations from the Original Macbeth

851 Words4 Pages

Mac Bethad mac Findlaích became king of the Scots after Duncan’s killing in 1040 and was murdered in 1057 by Malcolm III in battle . William Shakespeare immortalized Macbeth and his life story in his famous play which goes by the very same name: Macbeth. Shakespeare used Holinshed's Chronicles by Raphael Holinshed as his primary source, the basis for the plot of the play. Shakespeare made a considerable number of alterations in the story line and form. In this essay, I will explore what changes Shakespeare made and for what reason.
In Macbeth, a thane Macbeth hears a prophecy by three witches: he will be king. Macbeth decides to take help faith and kill king Duncan. His character changes dramatically in Shakespeare’s narration and finally…show more content…

Mac Bethad mac Findlaích became king of the Scots after Duncan’s killing in 1040 and was murdered in 1057 by Malcolm III in battle . William Shakespeare immortalized Macbeth and his life story in his famous play which goes by the very same name: Macbeth. Shakespeare used Holinshed's Chronicles by Raphael Holinshed as his primary source, the basis for the plot of the play. Shakespeare made a considerable number of alterations in the story line and form. In this essay, I will explore what changes Shakespeare made and for what reason.
In Macbeth, a thane Macbeth hears a prophecy by three witches: he will be king. Macbeth decides to take help faith and kill king Duncan. His character changes dramatically in Shakespeare’s narration and finally Macbeth is obsessed and is murdered a fearful man.
Holinshed wrote his Chronicles, the first edition published in 1577, with a straight-forward purpose: he wanted to inform his readers about “the Hiſtorie of Englãd” , which includes “Scotlande and Irelande”. Not surprisingly, Holinshed employed an objective means, in the form of a multivolume book, telling his audience about the history. He also stressed in his preface that he wanted to be as objective as possible and did not want to let his own opinions prevail. He based his work on ample historians’ scriptures of and many sources.
Shakespeare’s audience is, however, considerably different from Holinshed’s. Shakespeare wrote a play to be performed for all classes of people and carry a

Show More

Historical Macbeth Compared To Shakespeares Macbeth

Although most of Shakespeare's play " Mac Beth " is not historically accurate, MacBeth's life is the subject of the tragedy. There are characters and events that are based on true events and real persons but, Shakespeare's "MacBeth " differs significantly from history's MacBeth. The first example of a difference between the Shakespeare "MacBeth" and historical Mac Beth is the death of Duncan I. In Shakespeare's " Mac Beth ", Duncan I was murdered by MacBeth.

A prophecy said to Mac Beth by one of the three witches "All hail, MacBeth, that shalt be King hereafter1 ." was what prompted Gruoch, MacBeth's wife to plot the murder of Duncan I as he slept in their castle. In history, Mac Beth established himself as the King of Scots after killing his cousin Duncan I, in battle near Elgin not as in Shakespeare's play by killing him in his sleep. Duncan I was killed on August 14, 1040. Mac Beth then reigned as king for seventeen years.As previously stated Duncan I and Mac Beth were cousins, a fact not brought out in the play.

Shakespeare loosely based the play," Mac Beth " on events he found in Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles of England, Scotland, and Ireland. " Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles of England, Scotland, and Ireland, are the materials that furnished Shakespeare with his plot2. The chronicles were an account of the history of the country of which they came from. Another major difference, is that Duncan I was not the ageing and respected king Shakespeare makes him out to...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

'This dead butcher and his fiend-like queen.' Is this quote an accurate assessment of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth in Shakespeares 'Macbeth'?

847 words - 3 pages 'This dead butcher and his fiend-like queen.'The images portrayed by Macbeth and Lady Macbeth change dramatically throughout the play. I believe that the quote 'this dead butcher and his fiend-like queen' is not an accurate assessment of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth.Although there were elements of butchery in Macbeths behavior, he also had...

How Far Did William Shakespeare Manipulate Historical Facts For Dramatic Effect In MacBeth?

1159 words - 5 pages How far did William Shakespeare manipulate historical facts for dramatic effect in MacBeth? Although Shakespeare based his play MacBeth on "The...

Response to Shakespeare's Macbeth

1505 words - 6 pages Response to Shakespeare's Macbeth Look very carefully at Act 1, scene 3 (L.30 - 62) and comment on the significance of the witches' predictions. How do the witches affect what happens in the play, and how do you visualise them on stage? Throughout Shakespeare's life, witches and witchcraft were the objects of fevered fascination. Between 1560 and 1603 hundreds of people (nearly all women) were convicted as witches and...

Response to Shakespeare's Macbeth

5781 words - 23 pages Response to Shakespeare's Macbeth In act five, scene one the audience sees one of the many facets of Lady Macbeth's complex character as she is seen to be sleepwalking, while being carefully observed by her waiting gentlewoman and a doctor of physic. Her gentlewoman introduces this deranged behaviour, when she says, "Lo you, here she comes. This is her guise and, upon my life, fast asleep." There are many possibilities...

Lady Macbeth As A Catalyst To Evil

698 words - 3 pages The expression "behind every man, there is a woman," rings true even in the Shakespearean tragedy Macbeth. Lady Macbeth is the catalyst that ignites the fire to Macbeth's ambition. It is because she challenges his masculinity, questions his love, and belittles his...

From Harmony to Havoc in Macbeth

622 words - 2 pages Chaos is present where there are conflicting forces. In Act II of Macbeth, it certainly is existent, especially after the killing of Duncan. In the beginning of the play, Macbeth is a distinguished nobleman, who has a good reputation as a captain. He is loyal, courageous, and well respected by others, including the king. However, from the moment Macbeth hears the witches’ prophecies, disarray becomes progressively noticeable in Macbeth’s...

How ignorance leads Macbeth to his evildoing

1358 words - 5 pages PAGE PAGE 1 López Pablo LópezProfessor Andrés NavarreteShakespeare LET 17463 October, 2011How ignorance leads Macbeth to his evildoingIn order to introduce the topic, we need to understand that the origin of Macbeth's evildoing can have many possibilities at the moment of interpreting this character. However, I am going to focus mainly on the role of ignorance as the...

Difference and Similarites in the reaction to Duncan's murder seen in Macbeth and Lady Macbeth

1454 words - 6 pages When two people are in the same situation one would assume that their reactions would be similar in nature. However, each person has his or her own unique personality traits and emotions, which are reflected in their response to the event. One can see the distinct personality of each character in his/her response. This is clearly illustrated through Duncan's murder in Shakespeare's play, Macbeth. In Act II, scene ii, both

Shakespeare's Macbeth - Lady Macbeth and the Tragic Flaw Are to Blame

840 words - 3 pages Lady Macbeth and the Tragic Flaw Are to Blame       "...Go pronounce his present death,/ And with his former title greet Macbeth."  (Act 1, Scene 2, 64-65)     Though the word "death" in this sentence refers to the former thane of Cawdor's demise, Shakespeare uses the clever trick of foreshadowing Macbeth's downfall by coupling the word "death" with the word "Macbeth" so early in the tragedy.  The quote has another importance  it introduces...

Macbeth - Up to what extent is Macbeth responsible for Duncan´s murder?

759 words - 3 pages After having killed Duncan, Macbeth feels doomed and self-condemns himself in such way that when he “ha[s] most need of blessing”, he can “not say amen”. However, much has been debated whether the burden for having killed is only borne by Macbeth or if he shares the blame with somebody else. The purpose of the present essay is to state why I believe that Macbeth has killed only out of greed and is therefore doomed to hell...

Relative Influences on Macbeth to Kill his King in Shakespeare's Macbeth

2161 words - 9 pages Relative Influences on Macbeth to Kill his King in Shakespeare's Macbeth There were a number of factors that influenced Macbeth's decision whether to assassinate King Duncan or not. Each of these arguments worked for or against Macbeth's better judgement of the situation. Eventually, a combination of all these factors broke down his conscience through his mental weakness; this led to an unwise decision to kill the King. The consequences...